How to turn Black Friday customers into lifetime customers
Most of them don't order again. Here's what brings them back, and what to do this week.
By the Autora Lab team · Updated November 17, 2026 · 8 min read
Short answer
Black Friday morning, a new order comes in: #1043 for $182.00, from Priya Shah. Say it's her first order from your store. Will she ever order again?
For most new Black Friday and Cyber Monday (BFCM) shoppers, the honest answer is no. They came for the sale, and the sale ended. But you can keep Black Friday customers, and the first 90 days matter most.
Below are eight ways to bring them back, when each one works best, and a 90-day plan you can copy this week.
Do Black Friday customers come back?
Most don't. In a 2022 report on Black Friday 2021, Optimove found that only 16% of new customers bought again within six months.
Existing customers did twice as well: 33% bought again in the same six months. After one month, it was 8% of new customers against 15% of existing ones.
Optimove sells marketing software, and these numbers come from its clients' stores. It didn't say how many, so take them as a rough guide.
By the Numbers, a reports app for Shopify stores, looked at 1,299 stores in 2026. At the typical store, 6.6% of new customers ordered again within 30 days, 11.4% within 90 days and 19.5% within a year.
16% of new Black Friday customers bought again within six months, against 33% of existing customers
Optimove, 2022
6.6% of new customers ordered again within 30 days, at the typical store
By the Numbers, 2026
11.4% of new customers ordered again within 90 days
By the Numbers, 2026
19.5% of new customers ordered again within a year
By the Numbers, 2026
Compare the last two: 11.4% by day 90, and 19.5% by the end of the year. Each is for the typical store, so they don't add up exactly. Still, they hint that a lot of second orders come early, so the weeks after Black Friday matter.
Why don't they come back?
Usually nothing gives them a reason to. These are the common gaps:
- They came for a price, not for your store. When the sale ends, so does the reason.
- They don't know you yet. After one order, they may not remember your store's name.
- The store goes quiet, or sends only more sales emails.
Each way below closes one of these gaps. It gives a reason to come back, a good memory or an easy next step.
Eight ways to bring Black Friday customers back
The eight are a surprise gift, a short-dated coupon, subscriptions, referrals, a handwritten note, helpful emails, points and an easy second order. Pick two or three that fit your store.
1. A surprise thank-you gift
A small gift they didn't expect makes customers feel good about your store. Karlstad University found in 2026 that small, unexpected gifts make customers more loyal and more likely to come back. Even cheap gifts work.
The catch: it must feel like a thank-you, not a reward they had to earn. So don't promise it on your product pages. Let it be a surprise.
For Priya, that could be a Fern sticker sheet. Post-Purchase Gift adds it to her order at $0.00 once she has paid, so it ships with her items. She sees it on the thank you page, in her order email and in My Account.
It works best when the gift is small, goes with what they bought, and runs for a short time, like the Black Friday rush.
2. A next-order coupon with a short end date
A coupon for the next order gives a reason to come back soon, so keep the end date short. Shu and Gneezy's 2010 cafe study shows why, as our post on coupons that eat your profit explains.
Priya's coupon gives 10% off her next order and ends in 30 days. Post-Purchase Gift makes a code that only she can use, once. Just check that the discount still leaves you a profit.

3. Subscriptions for things people run out of
If people use up what you sell, let them get it on a schedule. With WooCommerce Subscriptions, customers pay weekly, monthly or yearly, and the order repeats by itself.
Coffee, tea, skin care and pet food fit well, because people use them up at a steady pace. Offer the subscription in your first email, while they are still using the first bag. A store like Good Ideas Studio, which sells mugs and prints, can skip this one.
4. Refer and earn
Ask happy customers to bring a friend, and reward them both. The Refer A Friend add-on for AutomateWoo gives each customer a link or a coupon to share. The friend can get a discount, and the customer earns store credit.
Referred customers tend to be good customers. A 2011 study in the Journal of Marketing followed about 10,000 customers of a German bank. Referred customers were worth at least 16% more than similar customers, and they stayed longer.
That was a bank, not a shop, so take it as a good sign, not a promise. Ask after the parcel arrives, once they like the product enough to talk about it.
5. A handwritten note
A few words in your own handwriting can bring people back. In a study presented at CUHK Business School in 2021, Professor Yan Zhang of the National University of Singapore followed 2,000 online shoppers for six months.
Shoppers who found a handwritten thank-you letter in their parcel bought again more often than shoppers who got no letter. Messy handwriting even worked better than neat handwriting, because it looked like the seller wrote it.
If you pack the orders yourself, this one is easy. One honest line is enough.
6. Helpful emails after delivery
Send emails that help people use what they bought, not only sales. Tell Priya how to hang her Fern print, or how to care for her mug.
AutomateWoo and MailPoet can send an email a set number of days after an order. Write it once, and it goes to every Black Friday customer. In MailPoet, an email sent after a wait counts as marketing, so only customers who subscribed get it.
These emails help most when the product needs care or setup, or a second product goes well with the first.
7. Loyalty points and early access to the next sale
Points give customers a reason to pick your store next time. With WooCommerce Points and Rewards, customers earn points on each order and use them as a discount on a later one. Points suit stores where people buy several times a year.
Early access is even simpler. Email past customers a day before your next sale opens. They get first pick, and it costs you nothing.
8. An easy second order
Make the second order take less effort than the first. Three things help:
- Accounts. In WooCommerce > Settings > Accounts & Privacy, let customers create an account when they check out.
- WooCommerce's Order again button. It shows on the order's page in My Account, once the order is Completed and the customer is logged in. One click fills the cart with the same items.
- Fast delivery. Send the tracking link and keep the date you promised. A late parcel spoils the first order.
Set this up before the sale, so every Black Friday customer can make an account.
A 90-day plan you can copy
One gift on the day she orders, then four emails you write once. This is how it looks for Priya's order.
Post-Purchase Gift does day 0 only. It doesn't send reminder emails, so write those in AutomateWoo or MailPoet.
Match the day 25 email to your coupon's end date. With a 30-day code, day 25 leaves 5 days.
What not to do
Don't chase them with more sales for everyone, and don't give the gift all year. Five mistakes to skip:
- More sales for everyone. In a PYMNTS Intelligence survey of 2,585 US shoppers in 2024, 41% said there are so many sales events that they seem less special. Send a personal coupon with an end date instead.
- A gift every time. Karlstad University warned in 2026 that gifts given too often get taken for granted. Give the surprise for the Black Friday rush, then turn it off.
- A coupon with no end date. It gives no reason to come back soon.
- Too many emails. Four useful ones in 90 days, like the plan above, are enough.
- Counting on the gift to grow Black Friday orders. Customers find it only after they pay, so it can only help with the order after.
What to do this week
Do these five things before Black Friday:
- Pick one small gift that goes with what you sell, like a sticker sheet. Check you have enough in stock. If it runs out, the order gets a note instead of the gift.
- Set it up in Gifts > Add New: pick Every order, then A free product or A coupon for the next order. A gift counts only for orders placed after you save it, so do it before the sale. Our Black Friday thank-you gift guide shows each screen.
- Turn on account creation in WooCommerce > Settings > Accounts & Privacy.
- Write the four emails from the plan in AutomateWoo or MailPoet.
- Put a stack of thank-you cards and a pen next to your packing table.
After Cyber Monday, turn the gift off with the switch on its row in Gifts > All Gifts, once any cash on delivery orders from the sale are Completed. The plugin has no schedule, so put the date in your calendar now.
Start with the gift, because it has to be in stock before the first Black Friday order comes in.
Questions store owners ask
How soon after Black Friday should I email new customers?
Start within a few days, with a helpful email rather than a sale. Then keep going for about 90 days. By the Numbers' 2026 study hints that many second orders come early: at the typical store, 11.4% of new customers ordered again within 90 days, and 19.5% within a year.
Should existing customers get the thank-you gift too?
Yes, if you can afford it. In Optimove's 2022 numbers, existing customers came back twice as often as new ones, so they are worth keeping too. To thank only new customers, open More options and set How often to "A customer's first order only".
Can I do this without a plugin?
Yes. You can put a small gift and a handwritten note in each parcel by hand. You can also make a coupon with an end date in Marketing > Coupons, but every customer shares that one code unless you make a new one for each. A plugin helps when there are too many orders to do by hand.
What if people rarely need a second one of my products?
Then the second order is often a gift for someone else, or a different product. Show items that go with the first one in your emails, and ask for referrals. Points and early access to your next sale give them a reason to pick your store.
Sources
- Optimove, new and existing customers on Black Friday and Cyber Monday (2022)
- By the Numbers, repeat purchase rate by industry (2026)
- Karlstad University, study on unexpected gifts (2026)
- Shu and Gneezy, Procrastination of enjoyable experiences, Journal of Marketing Research (2010)
- The National, report on the cafe voucher study (2010)
- Schmitt, Skiera and Van den Bulte, Referral programs and customer value, Journal of Marketing (2011)
- CUHK Business School, study of handwritten thank-you letters (2021)
- PYMNTS Intelligence, shopper survey on sales events (2024)
We make Post-Purchase Gift, the plugin in this post.