autora lab

Free gift rules in the UK, Germany and Australia

What the official sources say, what it means for a surprise gift, and what to do when an order comes back.

By the Autora Lab team · Updated November 17, 2026 · 8 min read

Short answer

Free gift rules in the UK, Germany and Australia mostly cover what you promise, so a surprise gift is the simplest case. In the UK, anything called "free" must cost nothing beyond delivery. In Germany, a gift the shop adds unasked usually stays with the customer after a return. In Australia, a gift you offer must arrive as promised.

On December 2, Priya Shah emails Good Ideas Studio from Germany. She wants to return her whole Black Friday order, #1043. Does the free Fern sticker sheet have to come back too? Questions like hers are when free gift rules start to matter.

Priya's answer is in the Germany section, and the UK and Australia get one each, with a link to every official source. The last part covers what happens to a gift when you cancel or refund an order.

Why is a surprise gift the safest kind?

Most free gift rules are about what you promise before the sale, and a surprise gift promises nothing.

Post-Purchase Gift, our plugin, works this way. It adds the gift after the customer pays, and she first sees it on the thank you page. So the gift was never part of the offer she said yes to.

That's our reading of the sources below, not a line from any of them. It also holds only while the gift stays a surprise. Once a banner or an email says "Free gift with every order", the rules for offers apply.

Cart gift plugins work the other way: the gift sits in her cart before she pays. In Germany, a gift in the cart at €0.00 can count as part of the sale, so it may have to come back after a return. Why free gift plugins break your cart covers that kind.

Free gift rules at a glance

Each country's rule fits in one line. The sections below give the detail and link each source.

CountryThe ruleWhat it means for a surprise gift
UKAnything called "free" must cost nothing beyond unavoidable delivery costs.The customer pays nothing for it, so the risk is low. If you advertise it, keep your prices the same.
GermanyA free extra the shop adds, or the customer ticks as an add-on while ordering, is a gift in law. One she puts in her cart at €0.00 is part of the sale.After a full return, the customer can usually keep a gift you added yourself.
AustraliaA gift you offer must be supplied as offered, and on time.Nothing was offered, so a sold-out gift breaks no promise. If you advertise it, keep enough in stock.

What are the free gift rules in the UK?

In the UK, anything you call "free" must cost the customer nothing, apart from the unavoidable cost of delivery.

The Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) sets out its rules in its advice on "free" claims (2026). For a gift with a purchase, the ASA says:

  • The gift must be separate from, and extra to, what the customer pays for.
  • You can't raise the price, or lower the quality, of the paid item to cover the gift.
  • Postage is the only cost you can charge, and you can't inflate it. No packing or handling fees.
  • Your ad must make clear what the customer has to do or buy to get it.

UK law says much the same. From 6 April 2025, the rules on unfair trading sit in the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act (DMCC Act).

The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) lists the rule as a banned practice in its guidance on unfair practices (2025). Its example: a shop advertises a "free" gift, then tells customers they must pay an extra fee to get it.

What changed in 2025 is how fines work. The law firm Pinsent Masons explained in 2024 that under the new law, the CMA can fine a business itself, without going to court first. The limit is £300,000 or 10% of the business's worldwide yearly sales (turnover), whichever is higher.

For a surprise gift, these rules rarely come up: you don't advertise it, and the customer pays nothing for it. Check the list above before you promote it.

Can a customer in Germany keep the free gift after a return?

Usually yes, if the gift was a free extra and not an item she put in her cart at €0.00.

In German, a free extra like this is a Zugabe. Two German legal guides, from IT-Recht Kanzlei (2019) and Händlerbund (2026), say the answer depends on how the gift got into the order:

  • You added it yourself, or she ticked it as a free add-on while ordering. Then it's a Schenkung, a gift in law (in everyday German, a Geschenk). If she cancels the whole order and sends it back (Widerruf), she can keep the gift, unless you clearly agreed otherwise.
  • She put it in her cart at €0.00, like a product. Then it's part of the sale, and it comes back with the rest.

Part returns are a different case. German law gives online shoppers no right to send back only part of an order, Händlerbund says, so you decide case by case.

Take IT-Recht Kanzlei's example: a €20 gift on orders of €100 or more. A customer orders €120 of goods and returns €40 worth. For the €80 she keeps, the shop would never have given the gift.

If you want a gift back in a case like that, say so before the sale: in the ad for the gift, and in your cancellation notice (Widerrufsbelehrung), your terms (AGB) and the promotion's own terms.

Post-Purchase Gift adds a product gift on its own, after payment. The customer has no choice in it, which matches the first case in both guides. A coupon for the next order is simpler still: there's nothing in the parcel to send back.

Advertising a free extra in Germany brings two more rules from Händlerbund's guide. Mark it clearly as a free extra, with its conditions easy to find. And "gratis" must mean free, apart from unavoidable shipping costs you state in advance.

What does the ACCC say about a gift with purchase?

In Australia, a gift you offer with a purchase must be supplied as offered, and on time.

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) explains this on its page about gifts and prizes (checked November 2026). It's illegal to offer a gift to promote a sale if you:

  • don't mean to supply it,
  • don't supply it as offered, or
  • don't supply it in the time you stated, or within a reasonable time if you didn't state one.

You aren't breaking the law if the failure was due to something beyond your control. You and the customer can also agree on a replacement gift. And you can't offer a free gift without telling customers they must pay for its delivery.

This matters for one thing the plugin does. If the gift product is out of stock, the order gets no gift, only an order note that says it "was not added because it is out of stock."

For a surprise gift, nobody was promised anything, so that's fine. If you advertise the gift in Australia, a sold-out gift can mean a gift not supplied as offered. So keep enough stock, and when that note appears, contact the customer and agree on a replacement.

What happens to the gift when you cancel or refund an order?

When an order's status becomes Cancelled or Refunded, the plugin removes that order's unused gift coupon.

It moves the code to the trash, so it no longer works at checkout. It also adds an order note that says so, with the code.

Priya's unused code in each case. Only a change of status removes it.

The plugin doesn't ask for a free product back. On a cancel, WooCommerce puts it back in stock with the other items, if you track its stock. Whether the customer returns it depends on your policy, and in Germany, on the rules above.

Cash on delivery works a little differently, because the coupon waits until the order is Completed. So if the customer refuses the parcel, no code is ever made. Our guide to free gifts on cash on delivery orders explains why.

One catch comes from WooCommerce itself. It counts the $0.00 gift line as an item still to refund. If you refund the full amount but leave the gift line's quantity empty, WooCommerce treats it as a partial refund, and the status doesn't change.

A WooCommerce order with the Fern sticker sheet at $0.00 marked Gift: Free, and order notes saying the free gift was added and the gift coupon was created.
Priya's order in WooCommerce. The Fern sticker sheet is a $0.00 line marked Gift: Free, and a refund still counts it as an item.

So after a full refund, check the order's Status. If it still says Processing or Completed, pick Refunded and click Update. The plugin then removes the unused code.

Does a partial refund take the gift back?

No. A partial refund doesn't change the order's status, so the gift and its code stay with the order.

Say Priya returns only her Fern print A3, and you refund $28.00. Her order stays Completed. She keeps the sticker sheet, and her 10% code still works.

The plugin can't tell whether that's fair, so this is a store policy matter. Decide once, write it in your returns policy, and treat every customer the same way.

For a small surprise gift, the simple policy is to let customers keep it. That also matches the German rule for a gift you added yourself.

A bigger gift tied to a minimum spend is different. You might want it back when a return takes the order below that amount. In Germany, that only works if you said so before the sale.

To stop a gift code by hand, delete it in Marketing > Coupons. Our post on coupons that eat your profit covers cleaning up old codes.

A short checklist for your store

Do these before your next sale:

  • Keep the gift a surprise, or read your countries' rules before a banner or email mentions it.
  • Selling to the UK? If you advertise the gift, charge nothing extra and keep your prices the same.
  • Selling to Australia? If you advertise the gift, keep enough in stock and watch your order notes.
  • Selling to Germany? Decide whether gifts come back after a return, and say so in your terms.
  • Add one line about gifts to your returns policy.
  • After every full refund, check that the order's status says Refunded.

Then ask a lawyer to read your terms and your returns policy once.

Questions store owners ask

Does a free gift change how much I refund?

No. The gift line is $0.00, so it adds nothing to the order total. A full refund pays back what the customer paid, with or without the gift.

What if the customer already used her gift code?

Then the plugin leaves it alone, because it removes only codes that haven't been used. Her second order keeps its discount, and the plugin doesn't change that order.

Is the customer told when her gift code is removed?

Not by the plugin. It adds an order note for you, but it sends her no email. Her order page in My Account still shows the code, so if she asks why it doesn't work, tell her it ended with the cancel or refund.

Sources

  1. ASA, advice on the use of "free" (2026)
  2. CMA, Unfair commercial practices guidance, CMA207 (2025)
  3. Pinsent Masons, DMCC Act overhauls UK consumer law enforcement (2024)
  4. IT-Recht Kanzlei, Zugaben bei (Teil-)Widerruf (2019)
  5. Händlerbund, Bonusartikel und die Werbung mit Gratiszugaben (2026)
  6. ACCC, Cash back offers, gifts and prizes (checked 2026)

We make Post-Purchase Gift, the plugin in this post.